| Sketch | McMullins House “Toothbrushers” |
| Norm MacDonald | ... | Don McMullins |
| Will Ferrell | ... | police officer |
| Tracy Morgan | ... | police officer |
| Cheri Oteri | ... | Colleen McMullins |
⁕Cheri Oteri refers to one of the trick-or-treaters as Lori Nasso, which is the name of a writer.
♬The Hit Crew - "Ghostbusters"