| Sketch | The Nativity |
| Emma Stone | ... | Mary |
| Beck Bennett | ... | wise man |
| Beck Bennett | ... | Gabriel Voice |
| Pete Davidson | ... | Barshaba |
| Kyle Mooney | ... | Joseph |
| Bobby Moynihan | ... | painter |
| Kenan Thompson | ... | wise man |
| Mikey Day | ... | Nicodemus |
| Alex Moffat | ... | wise man |