| Show | Star Search |
| Jay Leno | ... | Frank Jenkins |
| Joan Cusack | ... | Jennifer Jenclow |
| Robert Downey Jr. | ... | Mitzu |
| Nora Dunn | ... | Jenny Halloway |
| Jon Lovitz | ... | Franklin Schplotsel |
| Dennis Miller | ... | Kip Williams |
| Randy Quaid | ... | Ed McMahon |
| Terry Sweeney | ... | Slade McIntyre |
| Danitra Vance | ... | Claretta Dandridge |
| Damon Wayans | ... | The Angry Comic |
| Tom Davis | ... | announcer Voice |
⁕After one of his jokes, Damon Wayans imitates a rimshot. The band provides one immediately after, which causes him to break character.