| Show | Bill Swerski's Super Fans |
| Macaulay Culkin | ... | Tommy Arnold |
| George Wendt | ... | Bob Swerski |
| Kieran Culkin | ... | student |
| Beth Cahill | ... | Denise Swerski |
| Chris Farley | ... | Todd O'Connor |
| Chris Farley | ... | Mrs. O'Connor |
| Mike Myers | ... | Pat Arnold |
| Robert Smigel | ... | Carl Wollarski |