| Show | Tiger Beat's Ultra Super Duper Dreamy Love Show |
| Sarah Michelle Gellar | ... | Susie Jessica Dibbins |
| Howie Dorough | ||
| David Boreanaz | ||
| Seth Green | ||
| Ana Gasteyer | ... | Gladys Stubbs |
| Darrell Hammond | ... | Rene Open |
| Cheri Oteri | ... | Sarah Margaret Connolly |
| Molly Shannon | ... | Sissy Germane Daphne |