| Show | New York Underground |
| Fred Armisen | ... | Joshua Rainhorn |
| Will Forte | ... | Science Finger member Still |
| Bill Hader | ... | Trevor Dix |
| Amy Poehler | ... | Billamin Twin Still |
| Andy Samberg | ... | U-Turn Committee member Still |
| Kenan Thompson | ... | Rowboat member Still |
| Kristen Wiig | ... | U-Turn Committee member Still |
| Casey Wilson | ... | Billamin Twin Still |
| Colin Jost | ... | Rowboat member Still |
| John Lutz | ... | Rowboat member Still |
| John Mulaney | ... | Rowboat member Still |