| Show | The Music Man |
| Lin-Manuel Miranda | ... | salesman |
| Beck Bennett | ... | announcer Voice |
| Aidy Bryant | ... | Eulalie Shinn |
| Pete Davidson | ... | boy |
| Mikey Day | ... | townsperson |
| Kate McKinnon | ... | townsperson |
| Kyle Mooney | ... | Winthrop |
| Bobby Moynihan | ... | George Shinn |
| Cecily Strong | ... | townsperson |
| Kenan Thompson | ... | townsperson |
| Melissa Villaseñor | ... | Sally |
| Sasheer Zamata | ... | townsperson |