| Sketch | Nativity Play |
| Kevin Hart | ... | actor |
| Aidy Bryant | ... | host |
| Mikey Day | ... | actor |
| Heidi Gardner | ... | Terri |
| Leslie Jones | ... | audience member |
| Kate McKinnon | ... | actress |
| Alex Moffat | ... | Brian |
| Kyle Mooney | ... | actor |
| Cecily Strong | ... | Carrie |
| Kenan Thompson | ... | audience member |