| Cold Opening | The Last Supper |
| Mikey Day | ... | Jesus#1 |
| Andrew Dismukes | ... | apostle |
| Bowen Yang | ... | apostle |
| Marcello Hernández | ... | apostle |
| James Austin Johnson | ... | Donald Trump#14 Live |
| Molly Kearney | ... | Judas |
| Michael Longfellow | ... | apostle |
| Steve Higgins | ... | announcer Voice |
| Brady Bryson | ... | apostle |