| Show | Replacement Baseball |
| Morwenna Banks | ... | Vivien Ryan |
| Ellen Cleghorne | ... | Wilma Jobads |
| Chris Elliott | ... | Lew Morton |
| Chris Farley | ... | Ed Bambino Still |
| Michael McKean | ... | narrator Voice |
| Mark McKinney | ... | Jordan Kaminer |
| Tim Meadows | ... | Vernon Williams |
| Kevin Nealon | ... | Michael Glenson |
| Adam Sandler | ... | Anthony Carlone Still |
| Steve Koren | ... | replacement Padre Still |
| Ian Maxtone-Graham | ... | replacement Padre Still |