| Sketch | Save Broadway |
| Neil Patrick Harris | ... | Mark |
| Taylor Swift | ... | Annie |
| Fred Armisen | ... | Blue Man |
| Abby Elliott | ... | puppeteer |
| Bill Hader | ... | The Music Man |
| Darrell Hammond | ... | Stomp guy |
| Bobby Moynihan | ... | Mr. Mistoffelees |
| Andy Samberg | ... | Blue Man |
| John Solomon | ... | Blue Man |
| Jason Sudeikis | ... | The Phantom |
| Kenan Thompson | ... | writer |
| Michaela Watkins | ... | Elphaba |
| Kristen Wiig | ... | Chicago lady |
| Casey Wilson | ... | Chicago lady |