| Award Show | 2012 Psychic Awards |
| Lindsay Lohan | ... | Lucy |
| Fred Armisen | ... | Sheldrake The Inpenetrable |
| Vanessa Bayer | ... | audience member |
| Abby Elliott | ... | The Delightful Donna |
| Bill Hader | ... | Ayergen Ghost |
| Steve Higgins | ... | announcer Voice |
| Taran Killam | ... | Paolo di Avolo |
| Bobby Moynihan | ... | Terrific Vince |
| Nasim Pedrad | ... | The Stunning Amanda |
| Nasim Pedrad | ... | announcer Voice |
| Jay Pharoah | ... | Mysterio |
| Andy Samberg | ... | Dan Fernando |
| Jason Sudeikis | ... | magician |
| Kenan Thompson | ... | Ali Baboom |
| Kristen Wiig | ... | The Beautiful Angela |